When the Practice Walks Out the Door: Identifying Personal Goodwill in Provider-Dependent Professional Practices

Co-Sponsored by the National Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts®  (NACVA®) 

	Program Description		Who Should Attend
	How You Will Benefit		Schedule

Program Description
Few issues in professional practice valuation generate as much disagreement as the distinction between personal and enterprise goodwill. While the conceptual difference is widely accepted, its application in real-world engagements, particularly in litigation, remains inconsistent.

Nowhere is this more evident than in divorce proceedings, where the classification of goodwill can materially affect the outcome. The distinction between personal and enterprise goodwill is well established in valuation theory, with personal goodwill generally understood to be non-transferable and therefore distinct from the value of the business entity itself (see, e.g., Shannon P. Pratt, Valuing a Business; American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Statement on Standards for Valuation Services No. 1).

At its core, the problem is deceptively simple: Does the value of a practice reside in the business itself, or does it reside in the individual who operates it? In many provider-dependent practices, the answer is not immediately apparent. Financial statements may reflect stable, even growing, revenues, yet those revenues may be fundamentally dependent on the continued involvement of a specific individual.

The misclassification of goodwill often stems from an over-reliance on financial performance without sufficient attention to the underlying drivers of that performance. To address this gap, a structured framework is proposed to help valuation professionals consistently and defensibly identify personal goodwill.

How You Will Benefit
After completing this course, attendees will be able to:

• Identify the characteristics of professional practices in which goodwill is substantially dependent upon the continued presence, reputation, relationships, and personal efforts of a key practitioner
• Distinguish personal goodwill from enterprise goodwill by evaluating the economic attributes, contractual relationships, transferable systems, and other factors that support each component
• Analyze the sources of revenue generation within a professional practice to determine the extent to which earnings are attributable to an individual practitioner versus the business enterprise
• Evaluate the effect of practitioner departure on patient or client retention, referral relationships, workforce continuity, revenue stability, and the ongoing earning capacity of the practice
• Assess the transferability of goodwill by examining employment agreements, noncompetition provisions, referral networks, branding, operating systems, location, workforce, and other practice-specific factors
• Apply appropriate valuation concepts and methodologies when analyzing professional practices in which personal goodwill may represent a significant portion of total goodwill
• Recognize circumstances in which conventional capitalization or market-based valuation methods may overstate enterprise value by implicitly treating practitioner-dependent earnings as fully transferable
• Prepare a defensible allocation between personal and enterprise goodwill using financial analysis, qualitative evidence, professional judgment, and a clearly articulated valuation rationale

Take Aways
Upon completion of this course, attendees will be able to identify and distinguish personal goodwill from enterprise goodwill in professional practices. They will be able to analyze the extent to which a practice’s earnings, client or patient relationships, referral sources, and ongoing value depend upon the continued involvement of a key practitioner. Attendees will also be able to evaluate the transferability of goodwill and recognize circumstances in which traditional valuation methods may overstate enterprise value. Finally, they will be able to support and document a defensible allocation between personal and enterprise goodwill using relevant financial, operational, and qualitative evidence.

Who Should Attend

Delivery Method Group Internet-Based Program Level Advanced Advanced Preparation None Prerequisites Good knowledge of the topic and experience in the field. Advanced level programs are often appropriate for seasoned professionals within organizations; however, they may also be beneficial for other professionals with specialized knowledge in a subject area.   Accounting 1   Finance 1 Total CPE Hours   2

For NASBA sponsorship information, including refund, complaint, and/or program cancelation policies, click here.