Current Issue
Table of Contents
- “Let’s Have a Chat:” Applying ChatGPT and Other Large Language Models to the Practice of Forensic Accounting
- Cybersecurity Risk Disclosure Quality: Does It Affect the Cost of Debt?
- How Rules-Based Standard-Setting Facilitated the 2008 Subprime Crisis: Lessons from the “Qualifying Special-Purpose Entity Concept”
- Fraud Brainstorming Sessions and Interviews in a Remote World: Initial Evidence
- Canada’s Li-Cycle Holding Corporation: Innovative Technology and Innovative Accounting for Off-Take Agreements
- Self-Reporting Cash Tip Income for Income Tax Purposes
- In-House Preparation, Outsourcing, or Offshoring of Tax Services to Third-Party Service Providers: Does Disclosure to the Client Matter?
- Diffusion of Valuation Standards among Forensic Accountants Operating in Italian Courts: Exploring Some Inhibiting and Facilitating Factors
- What are the Determinants of Earnings Management for Misrepresentation? Evidence from Japan
- Book Reviews
Daniel Street
Joseph Wilck
Abstract: ChatGPT has captured the popular imagination because of its conversational voice, its wide scope of ‘knowledge’, and far-ranging abilities. In this article, we use an innovative interview method to introduce CPAs to ChatGPT, its development, and the current state of its capabilities. We then draw upon our own expertise to discuss the evolution of large language models (LLMs), suggest applications of LLMs in the field of accounting, critically evaluate LLMs’ current strengths and weaknesses, and propose five principles to effectively and safely leverage LLMs in the accounting domain.
Keywords: ChatGPT; large language models; Chatbots; AI
Back to Top
Dan Harris
Cemil Kuzey
Christine Naaman
Najib Sahyoun
Abstract: Since 2011, the SEC has required public firms to disclose their risks related to cybersecurity. Due to an increase of cyberattacks on U.S. firms, the SEC issued additional guidance to public firms on cybersecurity risk disclosure in 2018. This study investigates the association between the quality of cybersecurity risk disclosures and the cost of debt. We contribute to the literature by focusing on the U.S. debt market, which has been growing at fast rates in the last decade, whereas most of the extant research focuses on the equity market. Cybersecurity risk disclosures that are lengthy, more difficult to read, and contain litigious language decrease disclosure quality. We find that the lower the quality of cybersecurity risk disclosure, the higher the cost of debt. Our empirical results have important implications to management, board of directors, and regulators. The study demonstrates that cybersecurity risk disclosures need to be simplified, easy to read, and without boilerplate language that could be applicable to any firm.
Keywords: Cybersecurity risk disclosure; cost of debt; data breach; digital forensics
Back to Top
Alejandro Hazera
Abstract: Despite the strong post-Enron accounting reforms, banks repeated Enron-style earnings manipulation in the years leading up to the 2008 subprime bubble by using a loophole, known as the Qualifying Special Purpose Entity (QSPE), to move subprime loans off their balance sheets. In the post-bubble period, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) eliminated QSPEs (SFAS 166 and 167) and forced some big banks to re-recognize QSPEs' subprime loans. In some cases, high amounts of re-recognized loans forced the institutions to accept bailout assistance to remain solvent. Given these practices, this article examines accounting standards and exposure drafts regarding QSPEs to assess whether, in the years leading up to the bursting of the subprime bubble, constituent lobbying forced the FASB to delay reforms to the QSPE concept.
The issue addressed is whether the FASB attempted to resolve problems with QSPEs at the standard-setting level that could have been resolved more effectively, through auditor judgment, at the engagement level. Also, the effective failures of Bear Stearns and Citigroup are examined to explore whether auditors based unqualified audit opinions on the institutions' literal compliance with the QSPE rules rather than on the auditors' judgment regarding the economic substance of loan transfers to the banks' QSPEs. The chronology provides evidence that the FASB's deference to a knowingly faulty concept delayed needed reforms. Also, the cases suggest that auditors issued unqualified opinions on banks' literal compliance with the QSPE concept rather than on auditors' judgment. The review of standards and cases indicates that, during the emergence of asset bubbles and the current bank troubles, independent forensic and investigative auditors should review troubled banks' loans to assess non-fraudulent factors that may inflate troubled banks' loan portfolios. These lessons also apply to circumstances such as the recent collapse of Silicon Valley Bank, which require a deeper evaluation of long-term, accepted standards than is required by routine, periodic financial audits.
Keywords: Subprime crisis; rules-based accounting; bank loan accounting; special purpose entities; earnings manipulations
Back to Top
Gillian Rose Barnes
Dana R. Hermanson
Abstract: This study provides initial evidence about the perceived impact of the COVID-19 remote work environment on auditors’ fraud brainstorming sessions and fraud-related interviews. Interviews with 19 auditors from primarily local/regional accounting firms reveal that the remote environment is not significantly impacting auditors’ fraud brainstorming sessions. However, auditors perceive remote fraud-related interview sessions to be less effective than, but as efficient as, face-to-face interviews. Auditors’ inability to read non-verbal cues in the remote environment is hampering remote fraud-related interviews. Despite the recent challenges with fraud-related interviews, the interviewees typically believe that their ability to fully identify and consider all significant fraud risks and to maintain overall audit quality is not impaired. Rather, audit efficiency has declined as firms adjusted to remote work. Beyond the insights into auditors’ fraud-related procedures, the interviews also suggest that the remote environment is enhancing auditors’ personal flexibility but impairing the training of newer auditors. We encourage future research to complement the initial evidence in this article.
Keywords: Fraud; brainstorming; interview; auditor
Back to Top
Kang Cheng
D. Larry Crumbley
Abstract: To eliminate fossil fuel dependence, there is global pressure to move to all-electric vehicles, which calls for stronger batteries and an efficient recycling industry. Canada’s Li-Cycle Holding Company, allegedly the leader in battery-recycling with innovative technology, was initially listed on the NYSE on August 11, 2021, and successfully raised more than half a billion in capital. Within months, shareholders sued the company for questionable accounting and other business practices. This article addresses accounting issues raised in the class-action lawsuit.
The focus of the lawsuit is on an off-take agreement and the revenue recognized under this agreement. The issues are whether the contracted party is a customer or a broker; whether the sales are final; if so, then when and how to recognize revenue; and is it appropriate to subsequently adjust recognized revenue. Those issues are specifically addressed by the FASB Codification Topic 606 and IFRS 15. Contracts with third-party customers involved, such as Li-Cycle’s off-take agreement, are becoming more popular and complicated, and the appropriate accounting is open to debate. Reviewing this study helps clarify the lawsuit and the accounting treatments regulated by established accounting standards.
Keywords: Li-Cycle Holding Company; off-take agreement; take-or-pay agreement; Traxys; principal-agent relationship; contract with customers; Topic 606: Revenue Recognition; IFRS 15
Back to Top
Peter Kipp
Julia Mathew
Kayla N. Sapkota
Pradeep Sapkota
Abstract: In this study, we explore why college students that work in tip-producing jobs underreport tip income for tax purposes. While the IRS has provided clear and adequate guidelines on what constitutes tip income, the magnitude of underreporting is surprising, even if the IRS primarily relies on individuals self-reporting this type of income. Based on our survey data, we find that workplace culture plays a significant role in reporting practices. Most students are influenced by groupthink (rather than individual decision-making) when deciding not to report tip income. In addition, we conduct semi-structured discussions with the students and find that most students do not know the rules that pertain to self-reporting of tip income.
Keywords: Tip income; college students; income tax; tax evasion; tax avoidance
Back to Top
Renu Desai
Vikram Desai
Julia Davidyan
Andrew Felo
Abstract: The AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct (the “Code”) requires that if a member intends to use the services of a third-party service provider (TPSP), the client should be informed. However, the wording in the Code is not mandatory via the use of must. In addition, there is no differentiation between disclosures of outsourcing tax return preparation versus offshoring tax return preparation. This vagueness could be considered a significant area of concern because there are ethical considerations with disclosure, or lack thereof, and the economic considerations involved in offshoring of returns that are distinctly different from outsourcing returns within the U.S. This study presents direct evidence using experiments about how individual taxpayers might react to disclosures made by tax-preparers regarding their outsourcing or offshoring relationships with TPSPs. The findings confirm that taxpayers are not indifferent between outsourcing and offshoring of their returns. In addition, taxpayers would prefer clear disclosure of TPSP usage, including information about the TPSP’s location. Finally, results suggest the AICPA should require members to obtain clients’ specific consent (an opt-in option) to outsource tax return preparation to TPSPs.
Keywords: AICPA Code of Professional Conduct; tax preparation; disclosure; outsourcing; offshoring
Back to Top
Matteo Manera
Mariateresa Torchia
Gregory Moscato
Abstract: By reducing subjectivity and arbitrary decisions in courts, valuation standards are a powerful instrument, which can contribute to a fair trial. Nevertheless, adoption of valuation standards is not mandatory for forensic accountants in Italy. In this article, we explore the diffusion (a social process by which an innovation is communicated over time) of valuation standards among Italian forensic accountants, in terms of motivations, perceived benefits, and perceived barriers. We do this with the theoretical lenses of isomorphism and—as corollaries—of agency theory and signaling theory. This study relies on qualitative, exploratory research, based on 12 semi-structured interviews with expert forensic accountants conducted in 2021, aimed at exploring the perceptions of these professionals around valuation standards, in the five years that followed the introduction of Italian Standards of Valuation (PIV); that is from 2016 onwards. Our findings suggest that, although the vast majority of our small sample of forensic accountants praise the great work of the Italian standard setters in introducing valuation standards, most of them perceive that far less than 50 percent of the population of forensic accountants may use valuation standards in Italian courts. Waiting for future (quantitative) research to corroborate or refute our (purely qualitative) findings, which are based on a limited panel of interviewees, we propose a “trilogy” of recommendations for initial consideration by Italian stakeholders involved in the process of the diffusion of valuation standards.
Keywords: Italian forensic accounting; Italian Standards of Valuation; valuation standards adoption and diffusion; motivations; benefits; barriers
Back to Top
Masumi Nakashima
Abstract: This study explores whether six categories of earnings management determinants such as useful-decisions, financial performance, accounting standards, governance and internal controls, auditors, and law enforcement influence earnings management for misrepresentation simultaneously to validate the relationships. This study contributes to literature in the following ways. First, this study employs a structural equation modeling (SEM) by using the responses from the survey of 115 questionnaires from Chief Financial Officers (CFOs) of the public firms in Japan. It is likely that the sample comprises management from non-fraudulent firms that do not detect accounting fraud based on the textual analysis of MD&A disclosures. Second, this study presents a new framework that incorporates the theoretical concepts by applying the Theory of Planned Behavior, Protection Motivation Theory, and the Deterrence Theory to explain how variables influence earnings management for misrepresentation. The results of the analysis show that while accounting standards have a significant negative effect on earnings management for misrepresentation, governance and internal controls have a positive effect on earnings management to misrepresent earnings.
Keywords: Structural equation modeling; attitudes/rationalization; misrepresentation; earnings management; planned behavior theory; protection motivation theory
Book Reviews |
![]()
For Blood and Money
Nathan Vardi, 2023, 288 pp. W.W. Norton & Company 500 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10110 The author, managing editor at MarketWatch, reports how big money investors, hedge funds, private equity funds, Wall Street, and biopharma invented two of the biggest cancer drugs. The focus in the book is about what it takes to bring a wonder drug to market and save countless lives. Basically, the FDA has the power to make or break a company. He does this by telling a story of an upstart biotechnology company, Pharmacyclics, creating a one-of-a-kind cancer drug. The biotech team finds a rare molecule that seems to work on a vicious type of leukemia. As patients start rising from their hospice beds, the drug had overcome the obstacles like the chance that the buyer of a lottery ticket will win a jackpot. A forensic accountant, auditor, or valuator needs to know about the story of genius, pathos, and drama where vivid characters navigate a world of intrigue and morality. Excellent read! |
![]()
Tracers in the Dark: Global Hunt for the Crime Lords of Crytocurrency
Andy Greenberg, 2022, 367 pp. Doubleday Publishing 1745 Broadway New York, NY 10019 knopfdoubleday.com Cryptocurrencies transactions, such as Bitcoins, are no longer anonymous as a result of investigators who have cracked the Bitcoin blockchain. Drug dealers, money launderers, and human traffickers can no longer operate freely. Reading like a cat and mouse novel, this cybersecurity reporter provides a tale of criminal empires built and destroyed. Greenberg follows an IRS agent with a defiant streak, a Bitcoin-tracing Danish entrepreneur, and a colorful ensemble of hardboiled agents and prosecutors as they delve deep into the crypto-underworld. His product is a thrilling, globe-spanning story of dirty cops, drug bazaars, trafficking rings, and the biggest takedown of an online narcotics market in the history of the Internet. Auditors, accountants, tax practitioners, and forensic accountants will appreciate and learn how to find this illegal financing by following the money. |
![]()
When McKinsey Comes to Town: The Hidden Influence of the World’s Most Powerful Consulting Company
Walt Bogdanich and Michael Forsythe, 2022, 354 pp. Doubleday Publishing 1745 Broadway New York, NY 10019 www.doubleday.com Two prizewinning investigative journalists provide an unflattering portrait of the most prestigious consulting firm earning billions of dollars in consulting fees after conducting hundreds of interviews, obtaining tens of thousands of revelatory documents, and adhering to rule #1 of investigative reporting: Follow the money. This process is similar to the work a forensic accountant should do to avoid malpractice lawsuits. They suggest that their advice generally involves major cost-cutting, layoffs, and maintenance reductions to drive up short-term profits, which drives up their stock price and more money for executives at the expense of workers and safety measures. Columbia University Professor Joseph E. Stiglitz suggests that the authors show how the company optimizes corporate profits rather than social welfare. Many accountants remember that Jeff Skilling was a long-time McKinsey consultant before becoming CEO of Enron during their scandal. In Chapter 11, titled “The Enron Astros,” the authors note that on the opening day in May 2000, Astro’s Octavio Dotel threw the first pitch in Enron field. The naming right cost Enron $100 million, but the next year, Enron became the biggest bankruptcy in U.S. history. Other chapters in the book include:
|
![]()
One Honest Soul |
B![]() Professor Jennifer Taub, 2021, 368 pp. Penguin Books global. penguinrandomhouse.com Chapter one starts with some history of Indiana University’s sociology Professor Edwin Sutherland who is credited with developing the term white collar crime. Law Professor Taub argues there is an elite crime spree happening in America among the privileged perps. If you are rich and commit wire, mail, or bank fraud, you may be able to get away scot-free or a short stop in a minimum-security camp. She gives examples of the parents caught bribing to get their children into major universities and Wells Fargo & Company CEO John Stumpt who resigned in shame. But his Board of Directors granted him a $134 million golden parachute. Her premise is that there is a “too big to jail” syndrome. However, an argument can be made that white collar criminals are given higher sentences. For example, Enron’s Jeff Skilling, 24 years and Andrew Fastow, six years in prison. There are others serving long sentences: Bernie Madoff, 150 years; Rita Crundwell, 19 years and seven months (released early); Sholam Weiss, 845 years; Norman Schmidt, 330 years; Frederick Brandau, 55 years; Charles Lewis, 30 years; Dennis Kozlowski (up to 25 years); Allen Stanford, 100 years; Elizabeth Holmes, 11 years; Bernie Ebbers, 25 years; and Harriette Walters, 17.5 years. No cash bail, declining to prosecute crimes, defunding of the police, the current spike in crime, and liberal prosecutors in some states and cities in 2021, 2022, and 2023 have probably changed the premise of this author. |
Events
NACVA and the CTI’s Business Valuation & Financial Litigation Super Conference
December 14–15, 2023 | Hilton Fort Lauderdale, FL Beach Resort | https://www.nacva.com/conferences